God’s Away on Business

Slate’s Dahlia Lithwick is my favorite legal writer, because she invariably cuts through the bullshit and makes the U.S. Supreme Court sound fun and catty. She’s also excellent at clearly laying out the issues of a case and talking about it both legal and practical terms.

Yesterday’s dispatch on the words “under God” in the Pledge of Allegiance is a perfect example:

“The case is a mess because, whatever you may think about God or the pledge, if you really apply the case law and really think ‘God’ means ‘God,’ then Newdow [the plaintiff, who argues that the recitation of the pledge in school violates his daughter’s First Amendment rights] is right. But Newdow can’t be right. Can he?”

(The title of this entry is borrowed from Tom Waits, for no reason in particular.)

No Comments

Leave a comment

Latest Twitter Review

  • ‘Dragon Tattoo’ has a damaged, sharp heroine; compelling depravity; a fair mystery; and no fat. But it’s oddly amorphous and fixated on rape
    > More Twitter updates

Recent Comments

  • See A.O. Scott’s NYT review for a “That guy wrote exactly what I think.” moment.
  • How many times did we have to revisit Saito not...
  • I think Leonardo DiCaprio worked on both this and “Shutter Island” due to his apparent credo of collaborating with top filmmakers.
  • Oh, I’m in complete agreement that a critic should talk about whatever he wants to talk, and that people should read criticism only after seeing...
  • Spoon: I certainly don’t dispute that a completely blind movie experience can be a lot of fun. This was written in reaction to the excessive...
  • “I believe that plot is but one element of each movie, and that, almost always, foreknowledge of the full story detracts little from the overall...

Most-Read Entries

Other Voices

I'm a LAMB

  • bt_assoc_grey.jpg
Close