Twitter Review: Slumdog Millionaire

15 Apr 2009

Slumdog Millionaire - The climax? Salim interrupts. The dance? Credits intrude. Boyle trashes my minor goodwill with shit I don’t care about

http://twitter.com/Culture_Snob/statuses/1525109852

(Follow Culture Snob on Twitter.)

No Comments

Name

E-mail address (never shared)

Web site

Remember personal info?

Comments (You may use HTML tags for style)

Attaboy, Jim

In my hastily keyboarded notes after seeing Inception last weekend, I spent much time faulting Jim Emerson for his dismissal of Christopher Nolan and of the movie. Emerson made sweeping, unsupported generalizations in the service of his obvious dislike of...

Christopher Nolan’s Dead Women

In at least four of Christopher Nolan’s seven feature films, the plots and/or fixations are initiated or propelled by the death of a man’s spouse or girlfriend. Considering that Nolan’s primary thematic interest is obsession, isn’t this a little strange?...

Incepted

In taking down Christopher Nolan’s Inception, Jim Emerson writes: “[W]hat this movie’s facilely conceived CGI environments have to do with dreaming, as human beings experience dreams, I don’t know. ... [T]he movie’s concept of dreams as architectural labyrinths — stable...

Acts of Hashem

I was surprised after watching (and then reading reviews of) the Coen brothers’ A Serious Man that there was such a fervent (if small) backlash against it. The movie — about a Job-like Jewish professor in a Minnesota suburb in...

On Re-Creations

When I say that the filmed version of Watchmen and the horror remake Quarantine are faithful to the point of tedium, I intend that largely as a compliment. Great talent, care, time, and money have been spent not fixing what...

See A.O. Scott’s NYT review for a “That guy wrote exactly what I think.” moment.
How many times did we have to revisit Saito not...
Shawn
Incepted
I think Leonardo DiCaprio worked on both this and “Shutter Island” due to his apparent credo of collaborating with top filmmakers.
Mike
Incepted
Oh, I’m in complete agreement that a critic should talk about whatever he wants to talk, and that people should read criticism only after seeing...
Spoon
The Spoiler's Creed
Spoon: I certainly don’t dispute that a completely blind movie experience can be a lot of fun. This was written in reaction to the excessive...
Culture Snob
The Spoiler's Creed
“I believe that plot is but one element of each movie, and that, almost always, foreknowledge of the full story detracts little from the overall...
Spoon
The Spoiler's Creed

Twitter Review: Slumdog Millionaire

No Comments

Preview Your Comment

Leave a comment

Recent Entries

Attaboy, Jim

Christopher Nolan’s Dead Women

Incepted

Acts of Hashem

On Re-Creations

Latest Twitter Review

Recent Comments

Most-Read Entries

Most-Read Entries This Week

Recent Polls

Recent Audio Content

Recent Bookmarks

Latest Box Office

Other Voices

I'm a LAMB