That’s More Like It

eyes-wide-shut.jpgThe One-Line Review’s Iain Stott has followed up his The 50 Greatest Films project with Beyond the Canon, meant to address complaints that the first survey was too canonical.

The top five:

  1. Eyes Wide Shut;
  2. Mulholland Dr.;
  3. The Killing;
  4. Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind;
  5. Shadow of a Doubt.

The list is here. A different list, weighted for obscurity, is here.

The introduction and methodology are here. The list of 155 participants is here. My ballot is here.

It’s great fun to see which movies I was alone on (Clockers, Confessions of a Dangerous Mind, Incident at Loch Ness, and Trees Lounge, among others), and those on which I had unexpected company. Iain has done a tremendous job coordinating the project, compiling the results, and building the site so that everything is cross-referenced.

No Comments

Leave a comment

Latest Twitter Review

  • ‘Dragon Tattoo’ has a damaged, sharp heroine; compelling depravity; a fair mystery; and no fat. But it’s oddly amorphous and fixated on rape
    > More Twitter updates

Recent Comments

  • See A.O. Scott’s NYT review for a “That guy wrote exactly what I think.” moment.
  • How many times did we have to revisit Saito not...
  • I think Leonardo DiCaprio worked on both this and “Shutter Island” due to his apparent credo of collaborating with top filmmakers.
  • Oh, I’m in complete agreement that a critic should talk about whatever he wants to talk, and that people should read criticism only after seeing...
  • Spoon: I certainly don’t dispute that a completely blind movie experience can be a lot of fun. This was written in reaction to the excessive...
  • “I believe that plot is but one element of each movie, and that, almost always, foreknowledge of the full story detracts little from the overall...

Most-Read Entries

Other Voices

I'm a LAMB

  • bt_assoc_grey.jpg
Close